Hi,
Today I realized that my FC7, connected to MC8 was no more behaving as nicely as before.
The problem is this pedal, after calibration, is no more progressive, starting at 0% with 0 midi CC sent, if I move it to 10% it raises to 100 sent by CC. and soon jump to 127. No more progressive.
The law applyed to it is no more what was done before and it breaks all the usage I had previously
As I have not noticed when this change has occured, 3.9.7 could not be the culprit.
As all my other exp pedals, Boss and Behringer FC600 v2, work correctly, it seems that the change is related to the different pot value used in the Yamaha.
What pot value is the FC7 fitted with? The recommended has always been 10k. 25k may still work. We only made one change with regards to the reading of expression values but it shouldn’t affect anything.
Again, the recommended exp value has always been 10k. If you use an expression value outside of the recommendation, we can’t guarantee that it will work well.
I have been using this FC7 since the first MC6 I bought to control volume, maybe before you published this 10k pot value recommandation. The Yamaha is 50 k log and it has been working, as I recently rearrange my set , changed the instruments, and updated the presets concerning my exp pedals, I have not noticed immediately that it is now working differently. I am suspecting some change concerning the select exp law, actually it seems to have moved from linear to some log/exp making the pedal less sensitive to first moves as it immediately jumps from zero to ‘high’ values.
It would be a pain to have to change this very common pedal, Yamaha is widely used.
Seems like it has nothing to do with the potentiometer value. If it is a log taper, it would never have worked properly. Expression inputs always reads linearly. Linear pots needs to be used. Nothing changed with regards to this in every firmware we published.
So if you use the previous firmware, can you get it to work?
My bad, it appears the pot is linear. I was cheated by a bad geaspace thread that finally has been fixed and I checked by other sources, the Yamaha user doc only mentions 50K.
And this pedal has worked nicely with MCxx until some change, even with Source Audio Soleman and TC PX5.
I don’t know for the 3.9 and not sure the 3.8, I just started yesterday checking my new set with Select Exp on new midi channels after adding new Korg synths.
@CSurieux can you try this firmware are see if it resolves your issue? I rolled back the only modification we did that is related to the expression read.
So I get time to try ths morning.
Globally, it is a little better : with this when I move an angle of 15 degrees from Heel down I get 75% and it is possible to stay on value 10%, when on the last 3.9.7 at 15 degrees i am already on 85% and it impossible to set some % smaller than 75% as soon as I move. This results were obtained with the pedal calibrated with the 3.9.7 firmware (not the test one)
In details:
I realized that calibrating with this test firmware is totally different.
When doing the calibration heel down displays 3 and toe down displays 127.
After calibrating under the test firmware, the results are not as good : The heel down pos is at 3% (impossible to get 0%) and at 15 degrees I get 90%. The pedal does not cover the full range and is less progressive.
And without changing this calibration done on test firmware, when I reinstall the 3.9.7 , the heel down position starts at 64%, and jumps at 90% for 15 degrees. Totally broken in this case!
If I recalibrate with 3.9.7 (14-jan-22) when I set the heel down pos it displays 81 (where it is 3 with test firmware) and 127 for toe down. The pedals starts again at 0% and jumps at 90% for 15 degrees.
With this calibration, if I reinstall the test firmware, the pedal is again more progressive.
I am sure this pedal was more progressive before, I remember being able to play with values between 5% and 20% with graduated pression, which is impossible with the test version or the 3.9.7. I am sure because one of my ‘songs’ starts by serialy adding several instruments increasing slowly their volume from 0 to near 80%.
I fear that I will have to rotate this pedal with another one without the same mechanical quality : the FC-7 has a very good sensitivity and proposes a kind of mechanical boost feature which I have not found on other pedals.
EDIT : FC-7 now used on TC PX5 exp connection, replaced by a FC600 v2 on MC8 … we can close the subject.
EDIT 2 : I just tested with a 20k expression pedal from Beseco, same pb as with FC-7. So there are only BOSS FV-500 and Behringer FC600 working for me on MC8.